Oklahoma sued over anti-ESG law

An Oklahoma pensioner is challenging a state law that targets financial firms, including BlackRock Inc. and JPMorgan Chase & Co., for their climate change policies.

Don Keenan, a former state employee, is seeking a temporary restraining order against Oklahoma treasurer Todd Russ and the state over the 2022 law enacted by the Republican legislature. As part of the legislation, Russ released a list of six firms that are restricted from doing business with the state.

The lawsuit, filed on Monday in the district court of Oklahoma County, said the legislation is unconstitutional and violates the First Amendment. The states decision to use its retirees retirement funds as political fodder in its quixotic quest to prove a point is patently unconstitutional and violates federal law, Keenans lawyer said in the suit.

State governmental entities are exempt from the law if they find that divestment would be inconsistent with their fiduciary responsibility. The Oklahoma Public Employees Retirement System sought to use that carve-out so it wouldnt have to divest about $6 billion in pension assets managed by BlackRock, the Oklahoman reported. Russ criticized the use of that exemption. OPERS staff estimate that divestment from the restricted companies could cost about $10 million.

The Oklahoma Public Employees Association, which represents 32,000 state employees, is part of a coalition backing the lawsuit. OPEA wants to use the temporary injunction to prevent Russ from challenging the pensions vote or taking further action to enforce the law, executive director Tony DeSha said in an interview. The ultimate goal would be to get the law declared unconstitutional, he said. 

Other states, including Texas and West Virginia, have adopted similar laws to punish Wall Street firms for their environmental, social or governance stances. That anti-ESG rhetoric has snowballed into a hot-button political issue that has been debated in statehouses across the U.S. 

If we can beat it in deep red Oklahoma, then the other states that are going to see this law implemented they can beat it as well, DeSha said. 

Keenan previously served as president of the Oklahoma Public Employees Association. Collin Walke, a lawyer representing Keenan, declined to comment. 

The spirit and intention of the law is to protect Oklahomans and the economic base of the state, Russ said in an emailed statement.